If it’s time for you to embark on a roof replacement, odds are you’ll come across asphalt and metal roofing systems. As two of the most common roofing systems — albeit for different reasons — there are plenty of reasons to choose either design. Unfortunately, there can only be one, but how can a homeowner decide which roof is best for their home? By pooling our contractors’ knowledge, the Top Tier Roofing team will help you decide between the longevity of metal roofs and the security of asphalt shingle roofs. 

What Is an Asphalt Roof?

Asphalt roofs are the most common roofs installed, and odds are when you think of residential roofing, this will be the first thing on your mind. They’re extremely common for a reason, as asphalt roofs are budget-friendly, easy to maintain, and come in three types: 3-tab, dimensional, and luxury. 

Three-tab shingles are exactly what they sound like and are the most commonly installed asphalt roofing. Dimensional shingles come in a beautiful pattern replicating the look of wood shakes. Finally, luxury shingles replicate slate and come a bit larger than the other two options. 

What Is a Metal Roof?

Metal roofs are another common option for roofs, and for good reason. They are energy efficient, provide an excellent long-term prognosis, and don’t require much work to maintain.

Your roofing contractor will present two different options for your metal roof: standing seam and screw down. Standing seams are locked together mechanically at the seams, allowing them to expand and contract as the metal endures the brunt of the heat in summer. On the other hand, screw downs are just what you’d imagine, screwed straight down and with less flexibility for expansion or contraction.

Metal Roofs vs. Shingles

While both are great options and worthy of their status as the most common roofs, it’s important to dissect their long and short-term benefits. Even if you’re already leaning towards the aesthetic benefits of metal roofing panels, or intrigued by the simplicity of asphalt shingles, dive into the key features of both before you make your decision.

Metal Roofs Last Longer

On average, a metal roof will last about 40-70 years, with some lasting even longer under ideal circumstances. Much of that is due to its strength and durability, as metal roofs can withstand tough environments and don’t suffer from mold and mildew. Many metal roofs come with warranties that last longer than the typical asphalt roof, so you’re almost guaranteed to have an installation that lasts twice as long. 

Asphalt Roofs Are Cheaper

One of the main reasons asphalt roofs are preferred over other types is that they are much cheaper. Although they usually last about two decades, that’s still a long time for most homeowners, and it’s not as if asphalt roofs require a ton of maintenance. If you’re looking for the most affordable roofing option, asphalt roofs are the way to go. 

Metal Roofs Are More Eco-Friendly

Metal roofs are a great economical option for homeowners looking to save costs and the environment. Metal roofs are largely created from piles of recyclable material, meaning that even when yours eventually goes bad, it can be used again on something else. Additionally, metal roofs save energy costs by repelling heat from your home, whereas dark shingles may attract a bit more heat.

Asphalt Roofs May Be Easier to Install

Asphalt roofs are also easy for roofing contractors, and many contractors enjoy installing shingles on a home. Installing metal roofing requires a bit more expertise, but it’s nothing that a good roofing company can’t do. That being said, it does benefit homeowners who want to ensure lesser repair costs and an easier project to turn to an asphalt installation. 

Metal Roofs Require Less Maintenance

While asphalt roofs may be easier to install, metal roofs are easier to maintain. Standing seam metal roofs require little maintenance (besides inspections), while asphalt roofs should receive maintenance at least once a year. This is because metal roofs are much more durable and don’t have to deal with moisture and fungal growths that can eventually wear down the entire roofing system.

Whichever Roof You Choose, It’s Important to Get a Premium Installation

So which roof type is best for your home? It all depends on the qualities you value most. If you’re working on a budget or don’t care much for the longevity of your roof, an asphalt roof might be more appealing. If you want a long-lasting product that will look good and provide extra protection, a metal roof is your go-to. Either option is great, and regardless of your choice, the most important factor to consider is that you get yours installed by a professional.

You won’t be able to enjoy the benefits of asphalt or metal roofs if you get a faulty installation job. That’s why residents in and around Philadelphia and the counties of Bucks and Montgomery should contact Top Tier Roofing ASAP for a professional roofing system installation. Our contractors are some of the best roofers in the business, and we’ll help you decide which roof can provide you with the best short and long-term benefits for your home. Discover more about what makes us a top-tier roofing company by contacting us today!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.